The type()
and isinstance()
functions in Python are used for type checking, but they serve different purposes and behave differently. Here’s a breakdown of their key differences:
1. Inheritance Handling
type()
:
Checks the exact type of an object. It does not consider inheritance.
Example:
class Animal: pass
class Dog(Animal): pass
d = Dog()
print(type(d) is Dog) # True
print(type(d) is Animal) # False (exact match only)
isinstance()
:
Checks if an object is an instance of a class or any of its subclasses.
Example:
print(isinstance(d, Dog)) # True
print(isinstance(d, Animal)) # True (inheritance-aware)
2. Boolean vs. Integer Types
bool
is a subclass ofint
:isinstance(True, int)
returnsTrue
, buttype(True) is int
returnsFalse
.
Example:
print(isinstance(True, int)) # True (inheritance)
print(type(True) is int) # False (exact type is bool)
3. Multiple Type Checks
isinstance()
allows checking against multiple types using a tuple:
value = 42
print(isinstance(value, (int, float))) # True (checks int or float)
type()
requires explicit checks:
print(type(value) in (int, float)) # True
4. Performance
type()
is slightly faster for exact checks since it doesn’t traverse inheritance hierarchies.isinstance()
is more flexible but incurs overhead for checking parent classes.
5. Use Cases
- Use
type()
when: - You need an exact type match (e.g., distinguishing
bool
fromint
). - You explicitly want to exclude subclasses.
- Use
isinstance()
when: - Checking for any class in an inheritance hierarchy.
- Writing flexible code that accommodates subclasses.
- Handling multiple types (e.g.,
(int, float)
).
Example Summary
class Parent: pass
class Child(Parent): pass
obj = Child()
# type() behavior
print(type(obj) is Child) # True
print(type(obj) is Parent) # False
# isinstance() behavior
print(isinstance(obj, Child)) # True
print(isinstance(obj, Parent)) # True (inheritance-aware)
Key Takeaways
type()
: Exact type checks, no inheritance.isinstance()
: Inheritance-aware, supports multiple types.- Prefer
isinstance()
for most use cases to ensure compatibility with subclasses. - Use
type()
sparingly (e.g., distinguishingbool
fromint
).
Choose the method that aligns with your need for strict or flexible type checking!